Beirut-Era Veteran Urges Recognition
October 18, 2005
By JESSE LEAVENWORTH, Courant Staff Writer
One of the major milestones in the nation's continuing conflict with radical Islam was the bombing of the U.S. Marine barracks in Beirut. But Marine veteran Dave Seelye of Winsted says the hundreds of service members killed and wounded in the blast 22 years ago have been all but forgotten.
"You go to Memorial Day ceremonies and Veterans Day ceremonies and you hear of the veterans of World War I, World War II, Korea, Vietnam, the Persian Gulf and the wars of the present day in the Persian Gulf area," Seelye wrote in a press release. "But you never hear about the veterans of Beirut, Lebanon."
As he has done for the past several years, Seelye plans to shine a light on those veterans' service and sacrifice with a memorial ceremony scheduled for Sunday.
State Commissioner of Veterans Affairs Linda Schwartz is scheduled to speak at the ceremony, slated to begin at 1 p.m. at the All Wars Memorial on Route 202 in Bantam. Members of veterans groups, including Marine Corps League chapters from Torrington and Canaan, also are to attend.
Seelye served with the Marines in Beirut in 1982-83. He first organized a memorial service for the Beirut bombing victims in 1997.
American forces were in Lebanon as part of a multinational peacekeeping force. On April 18, 1983, the U.S. Embassy in Beirut was bombed, killing 16 Americans and wounding many others. On Oct. 23 of the same year, a truck loaded with explosives blew up outside the Marine barracks, destroying the building and killing 220 Marines and 21 other service members. Both attacks were ultimately traced to the terrorist organization Hezbollah.
Representatives of groups interested in attending the ceremony can call Seelye at 860-459-9016.
Politics & Policies: Marines came in peace
By CLAUDE SALHANI
UPI International Editor
WASHINGTON, Oct. 19 (UPI) -- Quite unlike the invasion of Iraq, the U.S. Marines in Lebanon came in peace -- and at the request of the Lebanese government. This Sunday, Oct. 23, will mark the 22nd anniversary of the bombing of the Marine barracks in Beirut where 241 U.S. servicemen, mostly Marines, lost their lives.
At approximately 6:22 a.m. on Sunday, Oct. 23, 1983, a lone terrorist driving a yellow Mercedes-Benz stake-bed truck loaded with explosives accelerated through the public parking lot south of the 24th Marine Amphibious Unit Battalion Landing Team headquarters building, detonating about 12,000 pounds of hexogen.
According to the official Department of Defense commission report, the force of the explosion ripped the building from its foundation. The building then imploded upon itself and almost all of the occupants were crushed or trapped inside the wreckage.
"It was one of the largest noises I've ever heard in my entire career," said retired Marine Maj. Robert T. Jordan, the 24th MAU public affairs officer at the time of the bombing. Jordan was in his rack in an adjacent building when the explosion split the still morning air and showered him with glass and pulverized concrete.
It was also the heaviest loss the Marine Corps suffered in any single day since the battle of Iwo Jima during World War II.
A few moments later another suicide bomber rammed his truck into the "Drakkar," a building occupied by French paratroopers. Fifty-eight French soldiers perished in this attack.
The Marines, the French, the Italian and the Brits had come in peace -- to help secure peace in Lebanon. How, and why, did they become the enemy?
First some history: the Lebanese civil war that had started in 1975 had entered a new phase. It was more of an undeclared lull, with Christians in east Beirut and the Muslim-Leftist-Palestinian alliance on the other side in West Beirut, each holding their ground. Beirut was living through an extended cease-fire. It was as though the combatants had grown tired of fighting. In addition to the dozens of armed militias, Palestinian commandos and Syrian regular forces controlled large swaths of the country.
On June 3, 1982, Israel's ambassador to Britain, Sholmo Argov, was shot as he left a dinner reception at London's Dorchester Hotel. The attack was carried out by three members of Abu Nidal's group, a renegade unit at odds with the Palestine Liberation Organization chief, Yasser Arafat. Argov was hit in the head, but survived.
Two days later, on June 5, Israel launched Operation Peace for Galilee -- a full-scale invasion of Lebanon. The invasion was initially designed to push back Palestinian forces operating in south Lebanon, north of the Litani River, thus placing their heavy artillery out of range of the Jewish settlements in the northern Galilee. However, then Defense Minister Ariel Sharon saw an opportunity to suppress the PLO once and for all, and pushed his troops all the way to Beirut.
Israeli forces, supported by their Lebanese Christian allies, laid siege to West Beirut for a grueling 88 days, pounding the city with heavy artillery as well as subjecting it to intense aerial and naval bombardments.
Eventually Philip Habib, President Reagan's special envoy to the Middle East, negotiated a cease-fire. The Palestinians agreed to leave Lebanon for new exiles in Tunisia, Algeria, Yemen and other countries so long as an international military force could protect the Palestinians who remained behind.
This saw the creation of the Multinational Force, consisting of U.S. Marines, French and Italian troops (the Brits later sent a token force). On Sunday, Aug. 21, Arafat, protected by French troops left Lebanon from Beirut's port, heading for Tunis. Over the next 12 days, 14,383 Palestinian commandos and Syria soldiers, as well as 644 women and children were dispersed around the Arab world.
Shortly after the departure of Arafat and the PLO, Reagan declared a premature victory and ordered the Marines out. "A job well done," he said.
On the afternoon of Sept. 14, 1982, Bachir Gemayel, Lebanon's president-elect, was killed by a massive car bomb in an office building in East Beirut. That evening -- with the multinational force gone -- Christian militias entered the Palestinian refugee camps of Sabra and Chatilla.
Approximately 1,300 people were massacred -- mostly Palestinians, but also some Lebanese, Syrians, etc. Afterward, though, many Palestinians disappeared from the Beirut Sports Stadium, where they had been detained. Hundreds of boys and men were trucked away never to appear again. To this day, no one really knows where all the bodies are buried, though apparently a huge number are undoubtedly in the mass grave within the camp. But that's another story.
After the massacre the Lebanese government asked for the return of the Multinational Force -- and they did return. They came in peace.
If mistakes were committed in Lebanon -- and they were -- blame should not befall the Marines, or the French paras who paid the ultimate price for peace.
The error was due to lack of coherent foreign policy coming from both Washington and Paris, and their unequivocal support of Lebanon's President Amin Gemayel. That is what lost the hearts and minds of a segment of the Lebanese population the Marines had worked so hard to win.
They had come in peace. Two hundred and forty-one of them never left.
To the editor:
On Sunday, Oct. 23, a ceremony will be held in Portsmouth marking
the anniversar y of an important event in our country's history. To
most Americans it will be just another Fall day, but for 241 families
it will be a sad reminder of a day of infamy.
Twenty two years ago, on Oct. 23, 1983, on another Sunday, a U.S.
Marine colonel, in a distant land, awoke about at about 5 a.m.to
prepare for another day of duty. As he began to shave, a tremendous
blast shook his building. He rushed to the window and could not believe
what he saw. A building that had been a few hundred feet away had
disappeared in a moment, All that remained was a huge smoldering pile
of concrete and mangled metal. Below the rubble lay 241 U.S. Marines
who had come to keep peace in a politically torn country. The place —
Beirut, Lebanon.
Nine Rhode Island Marines were among those who lost their lives that
day. Terrorism became a word that would open a new era in our history.
In Sept., 2001, it would reach our shores in New York, Pennsylvania and
Virginia. In Iraq, our military are endangered daily with car and
suicide bombings by the same forces of terror that took the lives of
our Marines. Beirut is but a faint memory in history.
This Sunday, Oct. 23, at 2 p.m., Marines, Navy personnel, families,
veterans and community will once again gather to remember the Marines
at a memorial service. It will be held at the Portsmouth Historical
Society on East Main Road at the coner of Union Street in Portsmouth.
Today, "Support Our Troops" decals can be seen everywhere. What
better way is there to show our support than to pay homage to those who
have already given their lives, that those who serve today will know,
should they fall, they will not be forgotten.
The public is invited to this memorial service and we hope you will
come and join with us to honor these men and their families who gave so
much that others might live in peace.
Shirley L. Zdanuk
Portsmouth
For the Portsmouth Beirut Memorial Committee.
A loss still felt, a war still fought October 24,2005 BY DIANE MOUSKOURIE DAILY NEWS STAFF
They came in peace - then they paid the ultimate price through an act of terrorism.
It was Oct. 23, 1983, when 220 Marines, 18 sailors and three soldiers - most from Camp Lejeune - died after a delivery truck packed with 12,000 pounds of explosives was rammed full force into the Beirut International Airport where the Marines had built a makeshift home and established headquarters.
The young men with the 1st Battalion, 8th Marines, the sailors and soldiers were on a peacekeeping mission to help a war-torn country. On Sunday in Jacksonville, many of their fathers and mothers, sisters, brothers, wives, active-duty military, veterans and friends gathered to honor their memory at the Beirut Memorial.
Marine Corps Commandant Gen. Michael W. Hagee, a former commanding officer of 1/8, said he remembers well the sacrifices.
"Words fail us," he told those assembled Sunday at the memorial site. "I wish we could say - as with many anniversaries - that this is a time for peaceful remembrance; that we were gathered today to commemorate a danger that had long since passed; or that the attack of 22 years ago marked the ending, not one of the early shots in a protracted and difficult conflict. But we cannot."
Hagee said those who lost a son, a father or a husband during this attack likely want to know why it happened. More than two decades after the incident, the answers are still impossible to grasp.
"It is hard for free people to comprehend the mix of extremism and hatred that leads terrorists to murder people sent to help," Hagee said. "But perhaps we can take solace in the fact that throughout human history there have been those who seek power through fear and mass murder, but eventually all of them, every one, have fallen."
After the laying of wreaths at the foot of the Beirut Memorial, Gen. Robert C. Dickerson, commanding general of Marine Corps Installations East and commander of Camp Lejeune; and Hagee stood at attention for a 21-gun salute. Following the hour-long service, several family members and former comrades walked to the memorial to pay tribute.
President of the American Gold Star Mothers Judith Young traveled from Morristown, N.J., to attend. It was a special time to remember her son, Sgt. Jeffrey Young, she said. He was 22 the day he died.
"You never really get over something like that, but time does make it easier," she said.
Evi Cox-Jordan flew in from Orlando, Fla., with her husband, Bob Jordan. Evi was a 25-year-old wife and mother when her first husband, Sgt. Manuel Cox, was killed in the explosion, she said through tears.
"He died two days after my youngest son was born," she said. "You never really recover; you just learn to deal with it."
Maj. Lew Vogler, executive officer with 1/8 shared a story that illustrates the irony of life, he said.
When Lt. Col. Scott Alley, the current commanding officer of 1/8, was a captain at basic school, a young student came to him and asked for leave so he could attend a memorial in Jacksonville, Vogler said. The captain told the young man that leave was not allowed for those in basic training. But when the young man told the captain it was a service to honor his father, Capt. Peter J. Scialabba, who had died in the Beirut attack, he let him go.
Alley was a senior in high school in 1983 and remembers the bombing.
"Fully considering the war on terrorism on June 30 we changed the call sign of our battalion to the way it was at the time of the bombing," Alley said.
He said losing 220 Marines in a battalion of about 800 was a significant loss then as it would be now.
"One is too many," Alley said. "We just had 21 Marines killed in action during our last deployment to Iraq. We need to keep sight of what we're doing and remember those who went before us so that we always do what's right."
And the war on terrorism, which some say began with the Beirut bombing, continues, Hagee said.
"America did not wish to send Marines abroad, but we sent them," Hagee said about the Beirut bombing. "We did not ask for violence, but we've answered it. We did not begin the war on terror, but we will win it."
Terrorism introduced itself to America with a smile.
Today, 22-years-ago in Beirut, Lebanon, a yellow delivery truck packed with 12,000 pounds of explosives and a driver with a death wish steered toward the Beirut International Airport, where Marines had built a makeshift home and established a headquarters.
The van broke through a barricade and barreled between two sentry posts. The guards, carrying only unloaded rifles, reportedly saw a grin stretched across the driver's face.
The van buried itself in the lobby of the building and exploded. The blast transformed four stories of cinderblock into rubble, ending the lives of 241 Marines, sailors and soldiers inside. The majority of the Marines were with Camp Lejeune's 1st Battalion, 8th Marines.
The circumstance in Beirut, 1983, is separated by years but not subject matter. In today's Corps, when about 61 percent of Marines are younger than 26, the large majority that are battling terrorists and insurgents in Iraq and Afghanistan were in swaddling clothes or not even born when that building fell down in Beirut.
But the Devil Dogs at Camp Lejeune, the home of the Beirut Memorial and 1/8, remember the attack. It's a lesson that will never be forgotten.
"Everything is a learning process," said Sgt. Dwayne Williams, 27, from New York, who joined the Marines in 1997. "It was unfortunate that the Marine Corps learned a lesson like that, but the best lessons are learned the hard way."
"I think about all the individuals whose lives were changed and families rearranged because of carelessness," said Staff Sgt. Eric Johnson, 30, who hails from New Willard, Texas. "But we are learning from our past. It's like a revolving door. As it revolves, we get smarter and smarter."
Lessons learned
When the Marines arrived in Beirut in 1982 as part of an international peacekeeping force, they were stepping into a boiling cauldron of civil war, regional strife and religious conflict. Massacres of civilians were perpetrated by both sides with gruesome frequency.
The conflict in Lebanon, a melting pot of religions and cultures, was primarily divided between Christians and Muslims, each supported by a number of armed militias. It was complicated by the Palestinian Liberation Organization moving into southern Lebanon, and Israel and Syria also occupying sections of the country. Beirut itself was divided, with Muslims controlling the western side and Christians the eastern portion.
U.S. forces landed in Beirut as peacekeepers trying to bring stability to the torn region and supply a measure of protection for civilians. So as not to show too aggressive a posture, the Marines guarding the headquarters at the Beirut airport were ordered to keep their rifles unloaded and on their shoulders and their magazines in their ammo pouches.
When the explosive-laden truck ripped past, the sentries did not have enough time to load their weapons.
The Long Commission, which investigated the bombing, concluded that "much needs to be done to prepare U.S. military forces to defend against and counter terrorism."
Lance Cpl. Darron Charles, a 20-year-old Marine with 1/8's Charlie Company and who has fought in Iraq, said that the Marine Corps has learned a lot from the tragedy.
"Now, that wouldn't have happened," Charles said. "When I think about it, they deprived us of our jobs as Marines. Now, we've got an aggressive defensive posture when it comes to ensuring Marines are taken care of. It was an eye opener.
"They say as Marines we learn something new everyday."
'I see the scars'
While all Marines learn about Beirut during boot camp, many come there without knowing much about it. Johnson did, because his uncle was in the Marines in the early 1980s. But Lance Cpl Jason Martin, 21, a member of Weapons Company, 1/8, said he knew that something bad happened in Beirut, but didn't know specifics until he joined the Marines and did some reading on his own.
"In my high school, it never was a big point in history class," Martin said. "But I think it's something that should be taught."
Williams and Charles also didn't know much about the bombing until they signed up. Which begs the question: why does such a loss of American life and an attack that was such an omen of times to come get so little attention?
"I feel if it doesn't happen on our soil, we don't care about it as Americans," Johnson said. "Look at anything that went down overseas. It doesn't hit people in their heads that these are our people, our brothers and sisters that are dying."
"It was tragic, but it wasn't 9/11, it wasn't Vietnam," Williams said. "That's why it isn't as well known, except by people who have been in the military or around the military."
Johnson, who has Marine friends who were wounded in the bombing, said that their bravery and sacrifice deserves to be remembered.
"I see the scars on their faces, I see the scars on their bodies," he said. "It was one of the worst things that ever happened to them. And they say, 'It made me stay in the Marine Corps to help protect what we are fighting for.' They are outstanding Marines."
While most Americans may not be aware of the bombing, the Marines do recognize the support they receive from the local community, which honors the fallen every year. Today at 2 p.m., the Commandant of the Marine Corps, Gen. Michael W. Hagee, will speak during the annual remembrance at the Beirut Memorial near Camp Johnson.
It's that type of ritual that keeps the memories alive - and spreads the word.
"Word travels, and if it's widely known here, it's going to spread out in the United States," Williams said. "It's definitely a good thing. They are still holding on and showing their love for what we do as Marines."
"You will always have someone here that passes it on to their kids," Johnson added. "I pass it on to my kids."
Martin said that he will always be connected to Beirut's fallen despite being born after the bombing.
"They should never be forgotten," he said. "I didn't know them personally, but they were Marines, they were from 1/8, which brings it close to home, even though it was before I was born. We know a little about them, but I think we should know more."
Upon my arrival in Jacksonville, NC, I was somewhat let down. I picked up the MCAS New River RotoVue, which contained a short article on Beirut that I had interviewed for the previous week. A quick glance at the Camp Lejeune Globe and the Jacksonville Daily News came up empty -- but a later check of the Globe showed a "Man in the Street" article asking where certain individuals were on Oct 23, 1983. A visit to the USO was also depressing. The Beirut Room didn't look much different from last year when it was undergoing repairs, except that some pictures of Beirut were laying on a couch as if repair was still underway and the rooms appeared to be used primarily for storage. One family arrived while Evi and I were checking our e-mail asking about the Beirut ceremonies. No one seemed to know. We shared what we knew and left. We found a half dozen vets and some family members at the Holiday Express. We discussed the 0600 candlelight service on Sunday. A couple of people took the initiative to bring candles--but no one appeared to be in charge. Evi and I arrived at the Memorial at 0530 on Sunday. Weather was pleasant for a change. The 9/11 Memorial is now adjacent to the Beirut Memorial (a large piece of girder from the Twin Towers dedicated to the men fighting in Iraq). We were please to see a chaplain preparing for a ceremony and about 35 or 40 vets and family member milling about -- but no one in charge. Several individuals asked if they could read the names on the section of the wall where their friends or family members names were engraved. I took charge and coordinated with the chaplain on how the ceremony would be conducted. The readings by vets and family members added a special touch to the ceremony. A reorganization at MCB Camp Lejeune evidently resulted in earlier LOIs about the Beirut Memorial ceremonies left some gaps that did not get filled. Also, being on Sunday, the regular scheduled were deferred to the afternoon and evening to accommodate those who wanted to attend church. The regular Memorial service was scheduled for 1400. We received work that the Recon service would be at 1530 and the devil Dogs at Camp Geiger would be at 1600. Later we were told that the Devil Dog ceremony (usually conducted at noon) would be at 1700. Only the main ceremony was listed in the Daily News. After breakfast at the Steel Kettle Restaurant, Evi and I went back to our room for a nap (we older folks need to do that when we can). We hit the small PX at MCAS New River, then headed over to the Memorial. We were pleased to see a large crowd assembling. CMC Gen. Hagee and Jacksonville's mayor delivered excellent speeches. About 100 family members and vets attended and several hundred locals from the town and military bases also were there. Some of the "hard corps" traveled from Indiana, Massachusetts, New York, New Jersey, Florida and Ohio. Media coverage was minimal. I did an interview with Channel 12 and with the City of Jacksonville videographer. A couple of print reporters were also doing interviews. Most of the out of town attendees left Sunday evening. Rich Ray was the only Jacksonville BVA members who I recognized in attendance at the ceremony. The Devil Dogs ceremony was attended by the "hard corps" vets and family members. It is rewarding to see that, as our Beirut warriors grow gray, the children and grandchildren of our vets are taking an interest in keeping the memory of their fathers' service alive. This may be the last ceremony at Geiger since road construction is making it difficult to get to or find the Geiger Memorial if you aren't familiar with the area. A recommendation is being made to move the Devil Dog Memorial to the site of the Beirut Memorial. The physical terrain in the area is changing. Bypass highways will soon direct traffic in totally unfamiliar patterns. Traffic passing the Beirut Memorial may soon be limited to locals and personnel stationed in the area. World War II, Korean and Vietnam Memorials may soon compete for attention and resources within the Memorial Park adjacent to the Beirut Memorial. That may be a good thing, however. BVA President John Perez and BVA Associate Board member Judy Young were the only officers or Board members to attend. No Board meeting was conducted. Next year is the 23rd Anniversary. Many of the BVA officers and Board members terms must be expiring. Planning needs to begin now not only for the 23rd and the 24th Remembrances, but for the 25th. The impression that I got from the vets and families is that they expect the BVA to take a significant role in the Remembrance every year. They also expect the BVA leadership to be aggressive in pursuing membership recruitment and renewals. The City of Jacksonville is dedicated to continuing the Beirut Remembrance. But I suspect that if family members and vets lose interest in attending .. and the BVA fails to provide leadership ... our motto: The First Duty is to Remember, may become a hollow phrase without meaning. Semper Fi! Bob Jordan Founding President Beirut Veterans of America